Transcript
March 10, 2026
When I've been up at Crestone and Richard Baker's been getting ready to talk, it always feels like it takes him about ten minutes, because he has all these layers of robes and people have to very slowly make several different offerings. And boy, by the time he's done, you're really ready to hear the talk. This feels very simple compared to that.
Good evening. But it's hard for —
So let's see where we go.
Tonight I would like to first continue to explore letting go, which is really all I said last night. So you didn't miss much.
If that. But if so, if that's all there is — and if it's the essence of hit the middle, and of refuge in an old shrine, and of the realm of the peaceful body establishing life — then, for example: what does it mean to be a peaceful body? What's a peaceful body establishing life? What's the realm of a peaceful body establishing life? And I was reminding myself that koans are more likely to want to deal with what is it like than what is it?
So if we hang out with what is it like — a realm of a peaceful body establishing life — we can allow our the, our sambhogakaya [?], our dream body, to meet that and see what emerges rather than trying to figure it out. But anyway, let's see where we go.
So again, the observation that letting go — when we get that fundamental, the fundamental instruction about meditation is to sit down and let go. So what is that? It's noticing that it's a whole body thing, this letting go. I imagine you've all been, you know, feeling some of that in the hall. The body lets go. And especially there are so many images with hands. Right. One of the reasons teachers have sticks is because it feels really good to hold on to one and stay connected to body when you're trying to speak about what can't really be said. You know, it's very helpful to have hands on. And so there's that phrase — to enter the world with life-giving hands. What's that? You know, we use our hands. They are our special feature as humans. These really well-developed hands — it's stuff plus, right. Certainly is not just the material it's made out of, to us.
So that bodily letting go — letting go with the hands. And, you know, when you're really tense, if you remember to really release your hands, already something's different. And the expression "grasping" — we think of grasping as something we do with our hands, right. And so there's also the letting go that the heart mind does, right. And is that separate? Well, no, not really. Although we kind of tease it apart a little bit. And we look at the body and heart mind from a little bit different perspective, I guess.
But that too is bodily. And you can feel that tension ease. You can feel the connection with Earth reestablished as the body and the heart and mind let go. We're here. And there are biochemical changes — as you all know — that are associated with that.
It's funny because, you know, we also use "letting go" — I didn't even think of this until now — but in the experience of nursing a baby, your breasts let go literally, and you can really feel it let go, in order to allow milk to come forth. And "letting down," I guess, is what they call it. But it's definitely a mostly involuntary letting go in response to a hungry baby, or at the time when a hungry baby would be with you if they're not.
And so that visceral feeling of letting go is very real in a lot of ways. Certainly the erotic connections are there too. And it's worth never forgetting that eros is definitely one of the energies of the letting go that we do in awakening. Without eros, you've got nothing, really and truly.
And so part of the expressions of that that I really loved was not only the book — I guess there was a movie too, but I haven't seen it — All the Light We Cannot See. And the knowledge that actually the physics of light are that light is only a tiny part, right, of a huge spectrum of energy, most of which we are not equipped to detect. So when we think about the radiance of the dark, you know, that also has a physical reality, right? And so there's not a separation, really, between light that we can see and light that we cannot see.
And so there are also a lot of elements of this life that we know without knowing, right — that affect us in ways that we don't comprehend, we don't have a structure for comprehending them. There's not a matrix, right. And so we are — I'm sure — all the time, actually, communicating with everything that is, in ways that we're just completely unaware of. And so the letting go is letting — is partly letting go of our identification with the things that we know we know, right. The ways that we know we're connected — we hang on to those so determinedly that when we really release our hold on our ways of knowing, things can get really different. And we can feel that. We may not be able to articulate it, but it's essential, really, to our survival, right. We're made that way. You've heard me say too many times: we're actually made of awakening, because if we weren't, we would be dead, right? Awakening is responding moment by moment by moment to what's really happening. If we were not so darn good at that, we wouldn't be in so much trouble right now.
So reciting the sutra service and the precepts can also be like this, right? We don't have to know how they change us, but entering them with a spirit of letting go, a spirit of handing over the reins, you know. So simply, for this moment, this brief moment of time, not holding back — giving ourselves to them completely, letting them take the reins. Oh, what a relief. I can feel it in the room when we do it. You know, there's this — all I have to do right now is say this, is follow the leader. And there's such a delight that comes when we do that. We're given it, right. We get the book in our hands and the leader says, "Okay, page one eleven" and off we go. What a gift.
And is this dangerous? You know, I may have told you all — at one time, a wonderful Muir Elder, Austin Bent Box [?], came to Woodman Roberts Elementary School. Some of us parents invited him, and he taught the kids about some of the ways. And part of the day was to sit quietly with eyes closed for a little while. Parents were outraged. We got angry letters because when you close your eyes, the devil can come in.
Yeah. So is it scary to relinquish — relinquish control? Well, those moms weren't the only people who feel that. We feel it. Which is one reason we have to come and sit down and have sore knees and backs for a week, because it takes some doing to release, to really release, and then release again, and then do it some more.
But in the service we do it and we're changed by it. And so it's dangerous to our status quo, right? It's dangerous to what we might think has been holding us together for years. And that's not nothing. And we're changed by it. And we do lose something. And so we don't lose our darkness, you know, which is just on the spectrum with our light. But we lose some of the blockage between our darkness and our light. And I was thinking about the koan about two monks raising the blinds — they do it exactly the same way. And the master looks over and says, "One gains, one loses." Or there are several different translations, but something like that. And of course, you know, could be the same one that gains and loses. And all the koans about the sword that kills, the sword that gives life — you know, that's not small. So when your sense of being a solid self begins to dissolve, or suddenly dissolves — that can happen.
It's good to be among friends, or be able to go be among friends, because it can be scary. And two things help us trust it, right — help us trust that dissolving of the blockage between our darkness and our light. And one of those is our bodies. To feel that your body trusts it — you know, can you believe your body when it tells you that you can trust this? It took me years, many years, to start to really feel that. Feel the way that I could trust my body, or could trust what my body trusts. It's more that.
You can feel it in a lover that you're not very sure about, right? That everything could be great, but your body doesn't quite trust that person — or does quite trust that person. There's a place where you're likely to be able to feel it, and as it comes through us, we also recognize it. Oh, yeah. This is me, really. This is how it really is. We can recognize it. There's a big difference between recall and recognition, right? I learned this as a teacher of reading and writing. You know, there's a lot that you can recognize but you can't recall. So here it's kind of like that. I might not be able to pull up that sense of unified experience, but I sure recognize it when it happens.
It's a true union of the vastness coming into the particular — how that works, what works and what doesn't. And it's particular to now.
I just loved the reading today. Thank you for leading us in that. Because of the how we get to laugh at our own certainties, right. And I would recommend to you an article if you can — I could probably find it for you. It's in the Harvard Magazine, courtesy of my son, who has no interest in it whatsoever. And it has really interesting articles. And there was one about a man studying bonobos over decades and finding that what was thought to be the common knowledge about them is very incomplete. And so I thought, yeah, like that, you know — we've all decided, okay, the bonobos, they're the ones, you know. And actually a lot is known about how they organize themselves now, more than was known. But there's got to be a ton more. So it was pretty fascinating. The females are in charge.
Anyway. So yeah. So last night we were talking about how, underneath the words we recite and read and write and speak about refuge — none of which actually captures it — we find that gesture, the gesture of opening, of letting go. Sometimes a bow, sometimes laughter. Sometimes tears, or a shout of forgetting to keep holding on — a release.
When we let go, we hit the middle. That is just this. This is the middle. And gratitude arises. There's this relief and gratitude. And along with that, the power of welcome.
So that other great koan came up where someone asked Master Ma: what should I do when things confront me from all sides? And Ma says: welcome.
Which brings us to another related koan, where Linji puts it — you know, wherever you are, if you take the role of host, where you stand will be a true place. That's also related to welcome and to let go.
Both the letting go and a letting come. So I want to talk about that part, because just letting go might help us empty our hands, but it's not yet reaching out a hand, is it.
And we forget. So when we forget our usual defenses against our lives and we let them in — and we offer our full attention, a willing ear, a just and loving gaze, right, as Simone Weil said — suddenly we realize that they just might, in their sometimes ugly, ugly costumes, become the awakening we've been waiting for all this time. Our lives, our very own lives as they are.
And so there was a poem, and I didn't have it printed, so that's what I brought my computer for. It's one I've known for a long time, and suddenly it just said: I'm coming. It's "Song of a Man Who Has Come Through" by D.H. Lawrence.
Not I, not I, but the wind that blows through me.
A fine wind is blowing the new direction of time.
If only I let it bear me, carry me.
If only it carry me.
If only I am sensitive, subtle, oh, delicate, a winged gift.
If only, most lovely of all, I yield myself
and am borne by the fine, fine wind
that takes its course through the chaos of the world
like a fine and exquisite chisel,
a wedge blade inserted.
If only I am keen and hard,
like the sheer tip of a wedge driven by invisible blows,
the rock will split, we shall come at the wonder,
we shall find the Hesperides.
Oh, for the wonder that bubbles into my soul.
I would be a good fountain, a good wellhead,
would blur no whisper, spoil no expression.
What is the knocking?
What is the knocking at the door in the night?
It is somebody wants to do us harm.
No, no, it is the three strange angels.
Admit them, admit them.
Is that not one gorgeous poem?
"Song of a Man Who Has Come Through." Yeah.
So — coming through. Right. When we recognize the three strange angels of our own very life. Right, just this — including all of it. The good, the bad, and the ugly.
And this is where a bodhisattva is born.
Out of this, this gesture of allowing ourselves to be awakened by the sounds of the world — letting go, letting in. Right. She who is enlightened by the sounds of the world.
We allow ourselves to experience the plenum, which is another word for emptiness, for vastness — the plenum, the fullness, the undivided fullness. And that is huger than huge, right, outside of which there is no outside of it. Or the vastness.
When we allow ourselves to experience the plenum — the way things come and go, arise and dissolve — just right in this room, right in the course of a day, the coming and going. I don't know how many people had dramas going on in the [zendo? chapel?] [?], but it happens. They come and go, arise and dissolve. All the wonders and all the suffering, the beauty and the horror. And we find, under and in and through the middle, a sort of self that is always here before anything.
And it called up — I think it might have been you, Michael, who was remembering — it also connects with: there is another world, and it's inside this one. Right. I think that's the middle we're talking about, right. Or at least it's one way of trying to talk about it. And what is it? It's you. What else?
Have you ever not been here? And this refuge, this kind of refuge, somehow sees us. As we see it, as we find the middle, and in the realm of the peaceful body establishing life, somehow finds us there before anything. And we want then, more than anything, to requite this love, to pledge our allegiance to it, to come forth. And lucky us, our tradition has help for us. We need it. And it's here.
So I've been wondering exactly where do these vows and precepts come from? The last time somebody asked me, it was like, oh. And so, lo and behold, a book jumped off the shelf. They do that before retreats on a fairly regular basis. And it was this sort of unbecoming little volume. I thought, really? And it's called The Path of Compassion: The Buddhist Precepts, the Chinese Brahma Net Sutra, and the introduction and translation is by Martine Batchelor. Some of you — she's written some books about Zen.
She's a Roshi married to Stephen Batchelor. And some of you will have read his work, with a foreword by the Dalai Lama. Just saying. Oh, isn't this wonderful — very Dalai Lama-esque. And so I learned really interesting-to-me stuff, and I'm going to lay some of it on here.
So the sixteen bodhisattva vows — in which we take refuge and which we take up as ours — have a very long history. They emerged — at least the ten that you know, the refuge vows — really from very shortly after the time of the Buddha, and pretty much all people who call themselves walkers on the Buddhist path say those around the world. The refuge vows. But these — but the ten Buddhist vows emerged at a time when the Mahayana was really forming, distinct from the Theravada traditions. So the Theravada tradition did and still does emphasize practices of loving kindness and compassion. And so, you know, you have metta practices and the Brahmaviharas, and many practices that are certainly what we would call bodhisattva practices.
But there's a difference. The emphasis there is on purifying and ending the cycle of life and death. So in Zen, the central vows of how to save all beings, and then cultivating the Buddhist precepts — these, she says (I'm quoting her here), are treasured as the foundation for an attitude of compassion to all of life, rather than being rules. So the Theravada tradition back then, as they were dividing, was really emerging as the tradition wanting to preserve as purely as possible the actual teachings of the Buddha. And that's a very valuable gift. And it's not lesser, but it is distinctly different than what our tradition — the Mahayana — was characterized by, which emerged really about the second century of the common era. So really early.
Was characterized by affirmation of the world in life. Right. It's not that your body is a bag of pus — and, well, that's pretty much a quote. And that life is, yeah, only trouble. And so what emerged was the bodhisattva ideal that vowed to save all beings, and the doctrine of emptiness. Apparently they emerged at about the same time, as the Mahayana was developing.
And it came from Buddhist teachings about no self. So if there is no reality to the self, then we end up with: form is exactly emptiness, emptiness exactly form. And then along with that came the emphasis on non-grasping, on letting go. Right. Because why hold on to something that's not real? It'll just get you in trouble. And it does indeed.
So then when the Brahma Net Sutra came to Japan, the precepts were adopted by Tendai monks in 822 CE. And then Dogen is the person who — after a time of decay, you know, because there are these cycles — restructured them into our sixteen: the three refuge vows, the three fundamental root vows of not doing harm, doing good, and benefiting all beings. I like that wording. And then the ten. So that's the history of ours. And I thought, you don't talk about it, but you might like to know that's a rough version of where they've been — and you know where they're going, because you are it.
Okay. So other notes from there. So Martine Batchelor comments that these precepts were used to defend and argue the case for the Mahayana when there were challenges to it. And you've seen it — you can really see it in the Lankavatara Sutra, which is also so much about distinguishing the Mahayana. And think about Vimalakirti. Right. Most of you may have read Joan's commentary on the Vimalakirti Sutra, which is really full of that — between the — what are they called — the Hinayana Buddhists and the bodhisattvas. So. And it's a little bit condescending — more than a little bit — you know, because they were trying to separate out.
So anyway. So the Buddha says: I uttered these precepts, which are always recited when one first gives rise to the mind which aspires for enlightenment — for the benefit of all. Which is also the definition Joan often gives us of a bodhisattva.
So it's interesting to think about our koan: how does the bodhisattva Guanyin use all those hands and eyes, if you think about it? Well, the response is: it's like reaching behind your head in the night for a pillow, right? That's a bodily answer, right? What does she do? What is that — the bodhisattva of compassion — what is that? Like, when she's doing what she does. And it's so much a natural human gesture, right? There's nothing about purity in it. And then the teacher asked, do you understand? And the student says yes. And the teacher says, well, what do you understand? And the student says, all over the body, hands and eyes. And the teacher says, well, that's a good try. That's — but that's not the whole thing. Well, what is it? Throughout the body, hands and eyes. And suddenly you're going: okay, exactly what body are we talking about? You know? And so you can feel — it's clearly it's your body, but it's also this big body, right? All the hands and eyes.
How does she do it — just like reaching behind her head in the night for a pillow? There's no sort of glorious purification to it. It's just like that, you know.
And. In the dark.
What do you do in the dark? Through and through. Everywhere. So it's your body all together that has this natural ability. Your hand can reach behind your head in the night for a pillow. And it needs cultivation — we know it does, right. Because we have the grief of screwing up over and over and over again. And so we know we need help.
And the other thing that just sort of thought that inserted itself — there was a sense of how it's easiest to let go with your hand when somebody is asking, when somebody reaches out, either reaches out for your hand, or there's something that your hand is needed for. And so the bodhisattva is one who lets go thoroughly enough to notice when that hand is wanted, is needed, right. When something is reaching out for your hand. And so this came along with teachings about emptiness — so interesting. So that we see both of those interwoven in our precepts.
So if you think about it: in the world where the Dharma is — there's your vastness reminder with every single precept. And then Dogen, bless him, comes along with: this is how it is, that's the same world. It's this world right in the vastness. There's no separation. In this world you better not kill, you know. So it's so lovely. It's exactly — reminders and continued training in how we are the hands of the vastness, how we come out of the vastness to do what needs to be done.
Hey! That's it.
——— Discussion ———
So we do have time for conversation.
Yeah.
Or we have time to sit.
We have time to do both. What a luxury.
Sarah, that distinction between Mahayana and Theravada [?] and the goal of enlightenment is interesting. Because in some ways — not you, but one — yeah, yeah, one could be judgmental about us. You know why? Maybe it's through experience that you feel that. Yeah, right. Because when I hear people say "I just want to be done, right," you know — and then there are others that are strongly on that path of: how could you feel like you want to be done when all of this is happening? Right. You know, and you know what — in my experience, yeah. But then you have to sort of get rid of that judgment call, because either person is doing good. Yeah, absolutely. And that's my experience — is that in the actual doing of it, you can get as many Zen people that are all tied up in their own whatever it is, as Theravada people, you know. And conversely, the generosity and the kindness and the openness and the joy that we find in people who really have been able to — whose lives have brought them to that place of openness and compassion and wherever they are. Right. But it's not Buddhism, you know. And so the distinction —
But I'll tell you what I really loved: when I was studying the seminal teachings of Trungpa — with all that baggage — but his seminal teachings come in three volumes: Hinayana, Mahayana, and Vajrayana. And he insists that each layer of practice is essential for everyone. So he sees them more as a developmental continuum. Yeah. And that made really good sense to me. The teachings in his volume about sitting down, you know, starting from the very beginning — when you sit down, what is a posture of release, what is a posture of dignity, of having a place on this earth, of being connected — all of that he's describing as Hinayana teachings.
And if you read the sutras that say, "somebody came to the Buddha and asked: how should a son or daughter of the Buddha sit and stand and walk?" — it's like, I just love that. There's a humility in the question: how should I begin? How should I hold this body on the earth?
So yeah. So I think it's — the thing is, when you're making a distinction between one way and another, you know, people talk stink about each other. But I hope you can feel the connection that I'm making from letting go to where we are with our bodhisattva vows, our deep central vow, and the expressions that help us on the road to coming forth. So it's the letting go and the letting in and the coming forth — those are the movements of this way as I'm describing it.
Anyway, tonight — that reminds me, Sarah, we were looking at some things Sunday night, and the one that talked about letting go as an act of generosity — yeah, you know, that's something you're giving to the world. Yeah. And there are so many layers of that for me that kind of just sunk in. And, you know, you think of letting go as — in a way — something you're losing, especially when you start to lose yourself, and it's scary as hell. Like, what am I, you know? And it feels like a big sacrifice. But then you look at what you're letting go of. And what is it? Why would you not be holding that anymore? Yeah. And what kind of — what is it that then you can bring into the world?
For you, yeah. You may — I can't remember — you're reading the Lankavatara. And in there there's a place where it gets to the eighth consciousness, and there's a section that talks about the forbearance of no self as being the challenge of advanced practice. The forbearance of it, because it's hard. Yeah, yeah. There's — like the Buddha's awakening story of Mara on him. And sometimes it almost feels like Mara comes to visit you, always terrorizing you.
On a limited basis.
Yeah, yeah.
And in that story of Mara visiting the Buddha — the thing that works for me is the greeting [?]: "Mara, my old friend. Welcome." Yeah — you're talking about welcome. Yeah, yeah, yeah. When we recognize that that visit is part of our awakening. Not an inhibition to it. Yeah, yeah.
When people would say the difficulties are great, you know, how to — yeah, freedom to — I kind of, it's hard sometimes. I feel like, yeah, yeah, whatever sucks.
But. It's like the universe offering those up to you — these are the things.
Yeah, yeah. The translation we were using when I first started practicing — for the bodhisattva vows, for the third vow — was: "Dharma gates are countless, I vow to wake to them." That was an interesting translation. But that sort of relates to what you're talking about.
This process that you're describing feels like such — what I'm going through in my move. Someone recently I was on the phone with talked about how: oh, you're moving. Therefore your very self is changing. Like, everything you think you know about yourself is shifting. Being in a new place, building new community, new relationships, even reorienting to existing ones — there's this shift that happens, and it's deeply disorienting at first. And I'm only a couple of weeks in, and I notice how hard it is to be in my body through that. It's like — like my mind just wants to escape the reality of that transformation going on in my body, because my mind doesn't really want to let go. Right? And I'm reminded of that. Like, I'll be in this really intense mood of just kind of a bit of dissociation and a bit of just like hyper focus on something, when my girlfriend will come home and like, her presence initially is just like, I get out of my face — because this is — I'm so like this. And then I'll call a friend who's known me for years and seen me go through many transitions, and I'll talk for two hours, and then I'll come back out and be like, "Oh, hi, I'm here, I've returned." Yeah. It was just — yeah, a process of letting go and letting in. And that feels really important in order to know how to be in this new place.
Oh, yeah.
Funny thing. You're taking refuge.
Which is not to say that's all it's about. But I think you've spoken of just trusting — trusting it. And that's that allowing yourself to be guided by what you don't know. Like that quote that I love: the sage sees by the light of her own confusion.
Shall we take a walk and then sit? Can I — oh, yeah. Good.
Lovely. You know, I relate a lot of this to ego and letting go of ego, but I'm wondering why teachers don't say that. Okay. Yeah. Good question. Some teachers do, you know — not so much in our line. And that is partly because, for one thing, ego is so much associated with what Freud taught about. So it has its sort of definition and its denotation and its connotations. And so ego as a term doesn't exactly correspond with the way we talk about a self when the self is self-focused and constrained in that way. And so we're more likely to talk about —
Well. Okay, so wait, I'm going to take a different tack. And I'd be interested to hear what other people feel in the room too. But ego has a negative connotation — you want to get rid of it, right? Actually ego is essential. And [the teacher] used to say: if somebody comes to me to practice and they don't have a good, solid ego, I will send them away.
So you need a pretty good degree of comfort with being a self — which we are — before you can really discover how we are not. And so it's not either we are or we are not. It's that if we say that the self has no independent reality — that recognition that there is no me, actually, that's separate from everything that I am made of and that I'm part of — then when I'm not recognizing that, I get into trouble. When I am recognizing the absence of a self, that could be just fine without any help, thank you very much. You know, "I'll do it myself." There's nothing we do by ourselves, you know. We don't breathe by ourselves, as you know.
Anyway. So still the concept of solidifying it, right — grasping, a certain sense of self. But that's why we don't so much use the word ego. Because actually, it's really important to recognize — just as important as recognizing that I am continuous with everything — that actually I don't have much idea what I am, right? Because if you remember that 96% of what exists right here and now is not perceptible by us — I don't know what I am, what makes me, what makes me able to raise a hand. I don't know, right? And so why would I insist on some idea of myself, which leads me to say things like, "they just don't understand me — if they would only understand me, everything would be much better."
Well, I don't understand me. How can I expect you to, you know. So I guess it's partly — at the same time, I have to recognize that I am an individual with a personal history and ancestry [?] and influenced by place. And I mean, we need no better demonstration than to know that children who are dying in Iran cause our hearts to break. Yeah. So we are distinct. It's just that we don't actually know much about what we are. Does that help at all?
Oh, sure. Yeah. And then also just realizing where the suffering comes into all of that. Yeah. Because that's where — if you can poke holes, whether it be in your self or your ego — you're able to breathe and engage. Right. Yeah. So solidified, yeah. So the more we're able to expand our field of understanding, the more that self can take its proper place in all of it, which is pretty small. So I love your description of ventilating. It's letting in what is bigger. Yeah. And what's uncertain.
And I've been trying to hold myself back from talking about the book that I'm reading [?], because I have to be careful not to rant away — it almost started me talking about it, but — it's called The Master and His Emissary, and it's all about left brain, right brain research. And it is so interesting because — not to oversimplify — but essentially the right hemisphere of the brain is this nonverbal but really kind of broad awareness. Basically, the idea is that both hemispheres of the brain are constantly operating, and they're basically two ways of being in the world that are happening at the same time. And to a pretty large degree, the left hemisphere of the brain — which is the verbal, conscious part — corresponds to what you might call ego, you know. It's the me. And it's concerned with tools and with getting, with survival.
And I think the author's point is that obviously we need it, because every creature with a brain has that function, yeah. So there's no kind of moral injunction to abolish that part of yourself. Yeah. But basically the right hemisphere of the brain, which is nonverbal but interestingly loves narrative and loves metaphor [?] and has access to much larger words — the left brain, the conscious brain, isn't aware of the right brain. It thinks it's in charge and it knows everything. But the right brain very much knows about the left brain, holds it, and makes space for it. And essentially the way that you access the mystery of the right brain is letting go.
I thought you were going to say music and art. Yeah, yeah, and that's letting go, actually. Yeah, exactly. Music and art and religious practice are all kind of these traditional ways of accessing that. But it's kind of like the tip-of-your-tongue phenomenon — you can't access it. You try really hard, and in releasing the tension, the letting go —
Yeah. So somebody today — was it you? — meeting with the koan about — it's like you meet a word you can't read, but you recognize the handwriting. That wasn't me. But I love that. So so so that's so great because, you know, your left brain can recognize it's a word. Your right brain recognizes the handwriting.
By that description. So a lot happened since I was studying neurology, but I was cautioned so many times — not only by my neurology professors but by my brother, who's a biologist — not to fall into simple models of right versus left. But a lot more is becoming known. Yeah. And apparently this guy tried to kind of quell the research for so long because of all the popular misconception about it. But actually the research is so compelling and so nuanced. Yeah. But it's real. Yeah.
Great. In that line — the book, A Stroke of Insight. Oh yeah. So you may enjoy that book. I can't remember the author. Have you read it? It's by — oh yeah, it's a woman who had a stroke. A stroke of insight. Right. She had a stroke on her left hemisphere. And so for a couple of days after that — she was really lucky that she was able to recover, even though it took a long time — but for several days afterwards, she was only able to experience life from the right hemisphere.
And it was unspeakably beautiful. It was kind of like three or four days of [satori?] [?]. However, she had a hard time finding herself, you know — walking across the street, all the things that the ego does to help us survive. And one thing that came up in the discussion of ego — not to be careless, because I'm probably projecting, but —
It's like, Roshi, have you noticed your problem?
There are documented cases of spiritual teachers of all varieties, beating down someone's feeling of "this isn't right, there's a problem here — alarm bells are going off with this spiritual teacher," or whoever, a person of authority. And they are beaten down, and it prevents them from responding with: "I've got to get the hell out of this, please."
And so it can be very useful. And maybe that's one of the reasons why, again, Roshi wanted someone with a solid sense of self. Anyways. It is important just that we can't be attached, that it's the only thing. Yeah.
Something I found interesting — I ended a lot of chakra meditation and guidance with that when I was more focused in my yoga practices. And so I had that background and it just seemed natural to me. And I carry that into a lot of my meditation. When I started in Zen, and then in med school when we're doing anatomy — and I ended up being a TA in three or four different classes: human anatomy — I was really profoundly struck by the amount of neural fibers and nuclei, or groupings of cell bodies, around the heart and in several areas in the belly that correspond to the areas of the chakras. Yeah, yeah. And with the exception of really the throat area [?], but that was a bit far away — I really started to appreciate it's all empirical. And heart-mind being a real and true thing, and your gut understanding of something. Yeah. I tried to talk to my brother about that, and he shut me down so fast. But I've always felt like it's not just a matter of, in some ways, that you just decide one day: I'm just going to let go, and then I'm going to have this massive awakening thing the first time you sit down. Right. Our connections need to be — connection. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I don't use that word "rewiring" anymore, because apparently if we start to think in terms of wires, then we're neglecting what actually is going on in those communications. But anyway. But you're saying reorganizing. And the — yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, that it takes — and you know, I'm a sort of cautionary tale. I'll tell you that in times when I haven't been meditating as much as I needed to be meditating, I could feel a deterioration of the connections. Yeah, yeah. When the koans — well, not just the koans, but sometimes the koans feel like they really are asking to let them be open. There's such an ache in my belly, such an ache in my heart. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then sometimes when the — there's also been — are they experienced as shifts? Yeah, how we want to term it. And sometimes that goes away. Yeah.
You just made me make another connection, which is — in all those koans that are in the commentaries, praising the teacher, expressing gratitude — huge gratitude for the power of the teacher's teaching — they'll say things like, "he opened his belly and displayed his guts," you know.
And. Yeah, they're talking about that a lot in the somatic psychology world — how many body-based and embodiment words are used for mental states, like in our vocabulary. And also now more and more, like vagal tone [?] — and that connection, again, trying to put words to things like integration, metabolizing — those types of words. Like bringing together. And trying to say, like, self — capital S Self — like that kind of self, you know? So it's very relevant in that world, in trying to integrate, bring together all of this. And I found it interesting because several of my mentors over the last several years, along with my own path, who've been in the sort of embodiment, somatic world, were all there at like really investing themselves in a spiritual aspect to body and mind, yeah, you know, more explicitly. Even though the roots are out there, because a lot of them are coming from a Buddhist lineage or a mindfulness background or something to begin with. But there's this — that direction of inclusion, where it's like a call for that.
Yeah. Well, and it feels like that's one of the gifts of the mindfulness movement, you know — that people have started to pay so much more attention to what their experience is. That's bodily. Yeah. Used to be like so divided — like, don't talk, like, disconnect. But I got in the —
One of my most favorite experiences from my internship was co-facilitating a mindfulness and addiction group with another person in graduate school who was in the contemplative program, and I was in the somatic program. And our — like clash — on things, because he was saying: "okay, we're going to sit, don't move. Be absolutely still, don't move." You know. And then I'm like, "if you notice that there's an impulse —" you know. And we just — and it was so wonderful. It was so wonderful because, yes to all of that — plus "don't move" doesn't actually even exist. Right, right. Yeah. Yeah. Well, a big part of his discovery in our time together was how informed the body is. And that ended up being part of his thesis then. And for me, coming into how precious silent stillness space is. Yeah. And also it was just like that gift. Yeah.
And I have no idea what you said, because all I could do was watch your hand.
Well.
Right brain. There you go. Here we go.
Well, I can't tell you how many times somebody who thinks they're not getting their koan is actually answering the koan with their hands and doesn't know it. And David Weinstein and I — you know, it's a sort of running joke — you just want to say, "you just answered the koan," but you have to let the person come through the hands to their understanding. That's somatic.
Yeah. Real quick — the first, like, meet-and-greet. I don't know, I talked about graduate school so much, but whatever. In graduate school, a bunch of dance movement therapists. It was just like a casual gathering, and everybody was like — and I went, and I'm like, I'm not going to be that person. Like, I — forward. I'm like — and then so funny. So yeah.
Tip of the tongue.
[Short side conversation about the Rodin Museum in Philadelphia — unclear] [?]
That's a kind of knowing for sure.
Okay. We still have time to sit a little bit. Let's take — shall we take a little walk? Yeah. And then sit a little bit. Let everything — let — partly I want to sit some because after we've been talking, there is a little bit of a time when it's hard to settle back into the silence that we're holding for a retreat. So if we sit first, it's easier. That's — no, I mean walk. Okay. All right. Let's do walking meditation. Okay.
Thank you.